Don't miss out! Join the thousands of people who subscribe to our once-daily email or our free miles and points Facebook group with all the best travel news. Some links on this page may pay me a commission - as always, thanks for your support if you use them

If you’re going to be doing any kind of manufactured spending or product or gift card reselling, you’re usually going to have to do a serious amount of volume to make it worthwhile.  Take gift card reselling for example – many deals are going to have a margin around 1%, meaning to make $1, you have to buy (and process) $100 in gift cards.

[SEE ALSO: How to get started in gift card reselling]

So in our example, to get even $100 of profit, you’ll have to buy $10,000 in gift cards.  Similar exercises could be done for product reselling or the buy gift cards turn them into money orders games that many people play.

But $10,000 starts sounding an awful lot like “real” money, and if you don’t keep track of that, you are going to end in a serious hole.  It doesn’t take much carelessness to wipe out MONTHS of profits.  Here’s my story

First, I lost 3 $988.50 money orders

Like many folks, I was playing the 5-back game when that was profitable (and easy) at CVS.  This entailed getting a lot of $988.50 money orders and was my first impetus in really tracking down my gift cards and making sure I wasn’t losing or forgetting any gift cards.  I was going through my records this morning and could not find 3 of my money orders (totaling nearly $3000).  I typically use mobile deposit to deposit my money orders, so I still have the actual physical money orders, but the bank I’ve been using had no records of these 3 money orders.

I looked all around my house trying to find them, giving myself a heart attack or 2, before realizing that these 3 money orders were the first 3 that I had bought, before my bank account at my current bank had been set up, so they had been deposited in my regular bank account.

Crisis averted!


Then I lost $2700 in gift cards

Later in the day, I was going through my gift cards that I’ve bought and trying to upgrade my spreadsheet of gift cards.  I have talked before about how I organize my gift cards physically, and that is still working for me, but up until today I had just been working on a spreadsheet with my card numbers, and it was getting hard to reconcile when I was getting paid by the various gift card resellers that I use.  What I settled on was using AirTable and we’ll see how that goes.

Anyway, I have been buying a particular brand of gift card that has been 20% off at Kroger lately.  I had bought a bunch of them on Tuesday and had those, but in going through my credit card statements, I found that I was missing 27 of them.  5 from Sat 2/21, 4 from Fri 2/27, 12 from Sat 2/28 and 6 more from another store on Sat 2/28.

I really started freaking out about those because I had ALREADY looked through everywhere this morning looking for the lost money orders.  I started looking through the trash, and picturing my kids helpfully “cleaning up” and throwing them out.  I even Googled “What to do if you lose a gift card” (answer, without the activation codes, you’re in trouble).

But then later in the evening, I found them.  They were actually in my gift card organizing boxes – I hadn’t spotted them earlier because I was looking for Kroger bags, apparently forgetting that I had earlier taken them out and rubber banded them together.

In any case, I was glad to have not actually lost any money today

What’s your worst story or closest call with losing high-ticket gift cards or other forms of money?

Sign up for our once-daily email with the latest tips and tricks on how to travel for free / cheap. 

You have Successfully Subscribed!