Don't miss out! Join the thousands of people who subscribe to our once-daily email or our free miles and points Facebook group with all the best travel news. Points With a Crew has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. Points With a Crew and CardRatings may receive a commission from card issuers.
A bizarre incident occurred last week where a United flight turned back while en route to its destination due to the plane being “too large”. At least this was the reason given from the flight deck that I’m sure left many passengers on-board scratching their heads. Why? The aircraft was an Embraer E175, a regional jet. You’d never expect this to be an issue for a plane so small.
An Embraer E175 is “too big”
While it may be on the larger end of the regional jet spectrum, I’ve never thought of an E175 as “too big” for anything. Honestly, it’s just the right size, and actually one of my favorite aircraft to fly (SEE: 3 reasons why the ERJ-175 is my favorite non-wide-body jet). That it is too large, at least from the perspective of being able to land at Chattanooga airport, is blatantly untrue. The passenger quoted in the USA Today article picked up on that fact immediately.
The plane headed back to O’Hare to the dismay of all on board. Finally, the reason for the U-turn was made at least marginally more clear to passengers once they were back on the ground in Chicago: Chattanooga doesn’t have the proper staff to handle the operational requirements of the E175.
That explanation sot of helps. I’m honestly still not sure what the specifics are for these “operational requirements”. Our tiny airport turns both SkyWest CRJ-200s and E175s with a pretty bare bones ground crew. We also have all of one gate and a staircase for boarding and unloading passengers. Maybe in 50 years we’ll get our first jet bridge.
Chattanooga does have jet bridges, and probably more ground staff than we do. The issue must either be that the staff are not trained to handle E175s, or there is some other operational issue underlying all of this. All the SkyWest spokesperson had to say was that the E175 is “just a different aircraft type” for Chattanooga ground staff.
United comes through
Passengers on the affected flight were eventually flown to their destination on a CRJ-200, the original equipment scheduled to operate the flight. However, they arrived around 8:30 p.m., approximately 3 hours late. This is par for the course with United, although it doesn’t typically include such a bizarre situation (SEE: United’s problem is…everything).
At least there was a bright side to the story for inconvenienced passengers. They were provided with a refund for their flight plus a $300 United travel voucher. I’d say the friendly skies covered themselves well on this one.
I’m still left scratching my head. Unless the equipment at Chattanooga Airport makes it impossible to deplane and board passengers (extremely unlikely), or the ground staff are not properly trained to handle the aircraft (possible, I guess?), why not operate the flight with whatever operational hiccup this might cause on the turn back to Chicago? What am I missing?
Points With a Crew has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. Points With a Crew and CardRatings may receive a commission from card issuers. Responses are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered. Other links on this page may also pay me a commission - as always, thanks for your support if you use them
There is a lot of ground equipment required to turn a plane. It’s possible that they didn’t have the right tow bars or some other small piece of equipment and weren’t able to find someone to borrow from.
Was this a one time flight? Seem kinda odd… They usually do a lot of planning before introducing a new aircraft on a route.
One of my kids was on a Virgin flight some years ago from New York to London which made an unscheduled landing at Shannon because one of the crew was sick. Everyone deplaned and went into the terminal. The passengers were told there would be a short delay until they could board again. After a 20 hour unscheduled overnight stop, the plane was towed out, made its way to the runway and took off. The passengers were told that the plane was of a type that didn’t usually land at Shannon and they did not have the required tow bar. One had to be flown in, together of course with a new crew. It cost Virgin a great deal of money putting up all the passengers in hotels, delay compensation etc. etc.
Sometimes there is a maintenance issue and they are only prepared to fix it at a hub. That happened to me once we were enroute we had to return to the hub so they could fix the plane because they were not prepared at the desti.